« June 2005 | Main | August 2005 »

July 2005 Archives

July 14, 2005

Council Winners Announced

Last week the Watcher's Council met and once again voted on the best Council and Non-Council blog post from a great set of nominated entries.

The winning Council entry comes from the Education Wonks - Border Freebies: Using the Race Card To Get an Education. The winning Non-Council entry comes from The Makaha Surf Report - Today I Leave for the War. Both were excellent.

You can find them and the full results at the Watcher of Weasels.

Also, for those looking to join the Council, a seat has opened up. Get the details here, and be sure and wish the Smarter Cop well.

July 12, 2005

Afterthoughts

A few hours have passed since Bill and I released the presentation on al-Qaeda and the International Islamic Front's attacks since 1998. The general response has been supportive and understanding of our intent. There have been some, as expected, detractors and others who wondered why this or that terrorist action was left out of the presentation. We purposefully left editorial commentary, methodology and personal ideology out of the presentation and, so, expected that to cause some discussion or disagreement. No problem.

Given the number of attacks, the range of organizations, the inescapable challenge of meeting others expectations or vision for such an effort, it seemed to us that we were better served by providing data on a limited number, an example set perhaps, of what Islamofascist aligned to varying degrees with al-Qaeda had been up to. This also enabled us to make the presentation manageable in terms of length, file size, etc.

Some have questioned our limited use of attacks in Afghanistan and Iraq, and frankly that is a justifiable concern, if it is the focus of ones view of the larger war. Our view remains broader. One critic of the presentation, who described it as a "mess" in a comment on one blog, and then challenged it further on his own blog saying "it is very clear to me that Roggio's and Hutchen[s’] flash animation really doesn't do anything to resolve the debate one way or another." That works for me. It wasn't meant to resolve the debate. It was meant to present a portion of the data and to remind those who, as do we all, have lives to live and aren’t constantly focused on these acts.

For those, like the above linked critic, who believe we've made an argument, and by leaving out data we've misrepresented the truth... I disagree. Each viewer brings with them a set of beliefs about the war (and any of its particular fronts) and in doing so this one has chosen to challenge our presumed takes without evidence of it in the presentation. Maybe it wouldn't be as concerning if a Ph.D wasn't attached to his name.

Specifically regarding Iraq and the oft discussed question of it's role in the war, and specifically whether or not it caused or inflamed current terrorist activities, or as the critic says - "expanded the recruitment pool and the broader base of support for Islamic terrorists" - again I must take issue. The base of al-Qaeda's or any Islamofascist organization's recruiting pool doesn't increase or decrease based on our action or any ability to support or deny the al-Qaeda narrative. The ideological fermentation begins without us and when it’s mature the new terrorist will act within the constraints of his convictions and resources available to him. Many peaceful Muslims stand beside tomorrow's terrorist in daily prayers with little to no knowledge of their ideological take or their proclivity toward terror. Is he a terrorist only when he begins to act on his belief or is he a terrorist when the rot of hatred consumes his heart and faith?

Others have also questioned the inclusion of Beslan in the presentation. While it wasn't the most straightforward of choices, the evidence and the State Department's words "Basayev has links to al-Qaeda" were enough to sway me toward the belief that Riyadh us-Saleheen Martyrs' Brigade and Shamil Basayev (who claimed responsibility for the act) are affiliated, although most likely not in a subordinate relationship, with al-Qaeda and the IIF movement and thus warranted inclusion. Additionally, al-Qaeda’s use of the Beslan attacks as a recruitment tool and rallying cry signified their ideological similarity making the decision easier. To exclude the Basayev led terror we would have to accept his word that he seeks only to defeat Russia, and to ignore his direct words of support for the terrorists in Iraq and elsewhere. In the end, that wasn’t something I could do.

As I noted in my earlier post, it’s your turn to discuss this and provide the commentary. I’ll have more to say later.

July 11, 2005

Presenting al-Qaeda

It wasn’t a work of joy. On occasion, there are things that should, or rather must, be done.

On Friday evening, Bill Roggio and I began discussing a presentation that to the two of us, clearly fit into this category. Our effort was to document, in a visual manner, al-Qaeda’s attacks since 1998 when the International Islamic Front declared war on you, me, and all those who refuse their radical view of Islam.

The result is a presentation available at Winds of Change.NET in the form of a Flash presentation.

It documents 30 attacks by al-Qaeda and its IIF affiliates since February of 1998. It by no means includes all al-Qaeda attacks during that time. Or all acts of terrorism. Instead, it’s a presentation of select acts of violence in 16 different countries and at the cost of thousands of lives. 4895 lives lost. More than 12345 wounded. As Bill notes in the accompanying post at Winds, many of the victims of al-Qaeda’s terrorism are Muslim. Whether they are collateral damage or purposefully targeted, given al-Qaeda’s ideological intolerance, is not as significant as the response of those under attack.

It’s that thought that remains with me at this hour after completing the presentation. When attacked, we have responded and altered the plans of Sheikh bin Laden and his band of falsely righteous cohorts. Soldiers, sailors, airmen and Marines have fallen in the battle to defend us, and the world, against an enemy all too comfortable with indiscriminate killing. Like many of you, and our nations leaders, I’m confident that we can (and will) win the war. That being the case, I can’t help but believe that those who sit by and watch while their religion is abducted for pure evil, while their sons and daughters are taught that death is preferred to life, and that it is morally excusable to commit acts of terrorism are the key to ending the war sooner rather than later, and at a lower cost in lives and turmoil. There are many Muslims who stand with us against al-Qaeda and the IIF. More are needed.

While on the subject, I’ll note that the musical accompaniment for the presentation is in Arabic. It’s title is Mohammad al-Mustafa or Mohammad the Chosen One. It wasn’t selected to stir the pot, so to speak, or to enflame the passions of those who will disagree with our editorial perspectives on the war or any other matter. It was simply a moving piece that, from my perspective at least, speaks volumes in Arabic and should reinforce a desire to see Islam no longer held captive by terrorist. To the ear unaccustomed to Arabic it is simple, resonating and perhaps somewhat haunting.

When looking at the data presented, it is minimal and without commentary or editorial opinion, as much as possible. Tell us what you think; provide the editorial commentary on your blog or in the comments section here or at Winds.

And to close, I’d like to thank Bill for the opportunity. As he notes, we shared a vision and the effort. We struggled with the content and its weight in sheer loss and strife. In the end, more importantly, we share a vision for the end of the war, for life without terrorism and for the role, even when insignificant, that we can play in helping to get the message out. That is a joy.

(Originally posted at The Fourth Rail.)

July 7, 2005

Council Winners Times Four

Having been absent for a while, I'm behind on recognizing the winners of the weekly Watcher's Council. I've now read them and am sorry I was late to the party.

For the week of June 10th, the full results are available at the Watcher of Weasels.

The council winner and those receiving votes -
Remembering Why I Love History by Right Wing Nut House - Winner with 2 2/3 votes. In a Perfect World, We’d Never Let Her Run by The Sundries Shack scored 1 2/3 votes. Faith, Smugness and Theocracy by Carpe Bonum, Clouding Men's Minds by Gates of Vienna, and Aid and Africa by Little Red Blog each tallied 1 vote. SF Stages Gala Offendapalooza by e-Claire, Political Mass Hysteria and the Marxist Drama by Dr. Sanity, Paris, the $6 Burger, and Things Yet to Come by Wallo World, Who's the Dummy Again? by The SmarterCop all received 2/3 votes. And A Sign of Things to Come by Rhymes With Right received 1/3 vote.

The non-council winner and those receiving votes - THIS is a Gulag by
Winds of Change - the winner with 3 1/3 votes. For Junior by Varifrank received 1 2/3 votes. Memorial Day 2005 by The Adventures of Chester, America Can't Play 'Lawful Stupid' by Cavalier's Guardian WatchBlog both received 1 1/3 votes. The Soros-ization of Ground Zero by Michelle Malkin, Beautiful Atrocities' Root Causes of Terrorism Timeline by Beautiful Atrocities, Leftist Hubris by New Sisyphus and Nightmares After a Close Call by T F Stern's Rantings each received 2/3 votes. Words Can Kill: The Semantics of the Schiavo Tragedy by TMH’s Bacon Bits and The Fallacy of the ABM Mentality by The Redhunter each received 1/3 vote.

For the week of June 17th, the full results are at the Watcher of Weasels.

From the council - What’s the Real Question in America? by The Sundries Shack was the winner with 2 1/3 votes. What the Hell's the Matter With US?!? by e-Claire received 2 votes. The Media and the Rise of International Terrorism by Dr. Sanity received 1 2/3 votes. The Slave Owner's Book Store by Gates of Vienna received 1 1/3 votes.

For the non-council entries - Zimbabwe Changed My Mind: Guns Are a Human Right at Winds of Change received 2 2/3 votes. Anti-Lynching Legislation by La Shawn Barber's Corner received 2 1/3 votes. Base Closure Hurts Thune (At Least We Sure Hope So.) by Kyzylkum received 1 vote.

For the week of June 24th, the full results are available at the Watcher of Weasels.

From the council members - Beautiful Indifference by Dr. Sanity won with 2 1/3 votes. If Only by Gates of Vienna received 2 votes.

The winning non-council entry - Kos Says U.S. Torture 'Equal' To that of Saddam Hussein (A Comparison) by The Jawa Report received 3 1/3 votes.

And for last week, the 1st of July - the full results are available at the Watcher of Weasels.

Last weeks winners were The Left's "Word Deficit" by Right Wing Nut House and from the non-council entries, Ehrlich's Wit and Wisdom by MaxedOutMama.

Congrats to all and now that I'm caught up, I hope that never happens again.

About:

July 2005 Archives:

This page contains all entries posted to LRB in July 2005. They are listed from oldest to newest.

June 2005 is the previous archive.

August 2005 is the next archive.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Licensed:

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Credits: